Polaris, Ohio · Checked September 11, 2026
One shop.
Two dessert bowls.
Enough for one banana pudding and one Biscoff cheesecake bowl. Prices are for full packages, with leftovers.
-
Budget substitute for the low-fat cream cheese.
-
Use milk you already have if possible.
-
Budget substitute for Nilla wafers. Choose the round vanilla wafers, not layered cream wafers.
-
Budget option: omit if the vanilla whey provides enough flavor.
-
Budget option: taste first and omit if already sweet enough.
Where to buy
Walmart Lewis Center Supercenter
8659 Columbus Pike, Lewis Center, OH 43035
A practical one-stop choice. Yogurt, whey, both pudding mixes, cookie butter, and vanilla had local pickup available when checked. Other prices are online estimates. Stock and prices can change; pickup and delivery fees depend on the order.
ALDI’s yogurt was listed at $2.79, and Kroger’s cheesecake pudding at $1.50. Those listings were not verified for local pickup. The small savings may not justify another stop. Target’s Biscoff listings were slightly more expensive.
Shopping research dated September 11, 2026. These are comparison links, not an order or a reservation. The basket is a practical low-cost option among the listings checked, not a guarantee of the lowest price everywhere.